Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe

If you have a sweet tooth and a love for nostalgic, comforting desserts, then the Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is going to become one of your absolute favorites. This luscious pie perfectly balances the rich, creamy texture of peanut butter with the light and fluffy whipped cream, all nestled inside a crisp pie crust. It’s a heavenly combination that feels like a warm hug on a plate, and each bite melts effortlessly, leaving you wanting just one more slice. Whether you’re serving it at a family gathering or an everyday treat, this Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie promises to charm everyone lucky enough to taste it.

Ingredients You’ll Need

Gathering these simple but essential ingredients sets the stage for a truly delightful dessert. Each component plays a specific role: the crust provides a crisp base, peanut butter adds rich flavor and texture, pudding brings creaminess, and whipped cream creates that irresistible airy finish.

• Pie crust (9-inch, baked and cooled): Provides the buttery, crisp foundation that holds all the creamy goodness together.
• 1/2 cup powdered sugar: Sweetens the peanut butter crumbles with a smooth texture and gentle sweetness.
• 1/4 cup creamy peanut butter: Helps form the first delicious layer of peanut butter crumbles with a smooth, nutty flavor.
• 1 packet (3.4 oz) instant Jell-O vanilla pudding mix: Adds a smooth, creamy vanilla base for the luscious filling.
• 1 1/2 cups milk: Activates the pudding mix and adds moisture to the filling for a silky texture.
• 1/2 cup peanut butter: Infuses the pudding with a rich, nutty flavor that turns this pie into a peanut butter lover’s dream.
• 1 cup whipped cream (or Cool Whip): Lightens the peanut butter pudding for a fluffy, melt-in-your-mouth feel.
• 2 cups whipped cream: The crowning glory that makes this pie so irresistibly creamy and visually inviting.

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Step 1: Create the Peanut Butter Crumbles

Start by mixing the powdered sugar and 1/4 cup creamy peanut butter in a medium bowl with an electric mixer. As you blend, watch for small peanut butter crumbles to form — like tiny nuggets of nutty delight. If the mixture seems dry or powdery, add just a few drops of water to help the nuggets come together. These crumbles are essential to add a surprising texture at the bottom and top of your pie. Once ready, take half these peanut butter crumbles and spread them evenly across your pie crust’s bottom. This layer adds a wonderful crunch and bursts of peanut flavor beneath the creamy filling.

Step 2: Whip Up the Peanut Butter Filling

Next, combine the vanilla pudding mix, milk, and the remaining 1/2 cup peanut butter in a mixing bowl. Beat them together for about two minutes until the mixture thickens into a smooth, velvety filling. Then gently fold in 1 cup of already whipped cream to lighten the pudding. This combination creates a luscious, creamy texture that’s rich but not too heavy. Pour this dreamy peanut butter filling over the peanut butter crumb layer inside the crust, smoothing it out for even coverage.

Step 3: Top with Whipped Cream and Remaining Crumbles

Now onto the pièce de résistance: your fluffy whipped cream topping. Spread 2 cups of whipped cream generously over the pudding layer, creating a soft pillow of sweetness. Then sprinkle the rest of the peanut butter crumbles on top, giving the pie that final touch of crunch, texture, and visual charm. Refrigerate the pie for at least 1 to 2 hours so everything sets perfectly. When chilled, the Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is ready to impress and delight with every bite.

How to Serve Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Garnishes

To elevate this classic pie, consider adding chopped roasted peanuts or a drizzle of melted chocolate on top for extra decadence. A sprinkle of crushed graham crackers or a dusting of cocoa powder can also add a touch of elegance and complementary crunch. These garnishes not only boost the flavor but make your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie look as irresistible as it tastes.

Side Dishes

The creamy richness of this pie pairs wonderfully with lighter side accompaniments. Fresh berries or a simple fruit salad offer a pleasant contrast in flavor and texture, balancing the pie’s sweetness. A scoop of vanilla ice cream alongside can turn this into an indulgent dessert experience that’s sure to satisfy anyone’s craving.

Creative Ways to Present

Try serving individual portions in mason jars layered with peanut butter crumbles and pie filling for a charming rustic touch. Another fun idea is to make mini Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pies using tartlet crusts for parties or gatherings, perfect for sharing your love of this classic with friends and family in a bite-sized form.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Leftover Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie can be stored covered in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Keep it wrapped tightly with plastic wrap or in an airtight container to prevent the crust from becoming soggy and to maintain that fresh whipped cream texture.

Freezing

If you want to freeze the pie, it’s best to freeze before adding the whipped cream topping. Wrap the entire pie tightly with plastic wrap and aluminum foil to avoid freezer burn. Freeze for up to one month. When ready, thaw overnight in the refrigerator and add fresh whipped cream before serving for the best experience.

Reheating

This pie is best enjoyed cold and doesn’t require reheating. The creamy texture and whipped topping are most delightful chilled. If you’re craving a warm dessert, consider pairing it with warm beverages instead.

FAQs

Can I use a homemade pie crust for the Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Absolutely! A homemade crust adds a wonderful buttery flavor and texture that complements the creamy filling beautifully. Just ensure it’s baked and cooled before assembling the pie.

Is it possible to use natural peanut butter in this recipe?

Yes, natural peanut butter can be used, but make sure it’s well-stirred and smooth for easier mixing. The flavor will be fresher and more peanut-forward, which many people love.

Can I substitute the instant pudding mix?

You can make homemade vanilla pudding, but instant pudding keeps the process quick and simple while delivering a reliably creamy result that works wonderfully in this recipe.

How long should I chill the pie before serving?

At least 1 to 2 hours of refrigeration is needed to allow the filling to set properly and the flavors to meld. For best results, overnight chilling is even better.

Can I make this pie dairy-free?

Yes, by using dairy-free whipped topping and milk alternatives, plus a dairy-free pie crust, you can adapt this recipe to suit dietary needs without sacrificing flavor.

Final Thoughts

The Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is more than just a dessert; it’s a delightful experience that brings comfort and joy in every bite. Its effortless layers of creamy peanut butter and light whipped cream wrapped in a flaky crust create a timeless treat you’ll want to make again and again. Give this recipe a try — your taste buds will thank you and your friends and family will be asking for seconds in no time!

Print